Search This Blog

Sunday, June 16, 2019

The Calculating Stars: A Woman's Fight To Be An Astronaut in an Alternate Timeline

I'm seriously interested in woman aviators.  The very first post on this blog was a review of a novel dealing with Russian WWII ace Lydia Litvyak which appeared here.   My most recent post on this blog dealing with a woman pilot was a review of The Lost Pilots which I wrote about a year ago. It can be found here. I'm also fascinated by woman astronauts.

It's these enthusiasms that made me such a fan of Mary Robinette Kowal's  Lady Astronaut series which she began with a succession of several short stories that I read first.  They can be found in Kowal's anthology, Word Puppets.  Though I have just learned that there is a more recent Lady Astronaut story that I haven't yet read called "Articulated Restraint" that takes place between the first two Lady Astronaut novels.  I immediately purchased it from Amazon.

My only problem with reading the first Lady Astronaut novel, The Calculating Stars, was setting aside the time to do it when I have so many review commitments.  A buddy read on a Goodreads group gave me an excuse to shoehorn it in between a background book for a July blog tour novel, and an ARC I won  that I'm supposed to be tweeting about this month.  I'm just glad that I finally got to The Calculating Stars.

                           



The protagonist, Elma York, was a Women's Airforce  Service Pilot (WASP) in WWII.  I'm a WASP afficionado too.  On this blog,  I wrote a review of  Marge Piercy's  Gone To Soldiers which contained a character who was a WASP.  You can read that review here. 

 Elma also had a strong background in mathematics and physics which qualified her to be a computer.   Before the existence of machines called computers, humans known as computers did calculations.  Many readers will have learned about them from the movie called Hidden Figures about African-American women who were computers for the American space program.

In the Lady Astronaut series the American space program was launched under different circumstances.  It takes place in an alternate timeline in which a meteor fell on Washington D.C. in 1952, killed a great many people and altered Earth's climate.  It was decided that finding a new home for humanity should be an urgent priority.   Although I was pleased to see that the space program was regarded as vitally important, I wondered why there wasn't any serious consideration being given to the possibility of interventions that would prevent severe climate change.      

I also have a small quibble over Elma's Jewish background.  Her ancestors were apparently Yiddish speaking Ashkenazis like mine.  Yet she says that they settled in Charleston, South Carolina in the 18th century.  The Jews that arrived in Charleston during that period were Sephardic.  Sephardic Jews were originally from Spain.  They spoke a Spanish derived language called Ladino rather than Yiddish.   According to  the Jewish Virtual Library's page about Charleston's Jewish history here, there was no Ashkenazi synagogue in Charleston until 1854. 

Yet I was so inspired by Elma's struggle to open the space  program to women who were pilots.  So I'd definitely give this novel five stars.

                                               


                           

Saturday, June 15, 2019

Reign of Mist: A Satisfying Middle Book of a Trilogy

Reign of Mist was sent to me by author Helen Scheuerer via Book Funnel, so that I could catch up on the earlier books in the YA epic fantasy Oremere trilogy before participating in the blog tour for the final novel in the trilogy, War of the Mist. I reviewed the first volume, Heart of Mist on this blog here.   My non-spoiler review for Reign of Mist is below.

                       


   In Reign of Mist, the characters that were introduced in Heart of Mist are developed further.  This means that these familiar characters and their relationships are portrayed with more depth.  The characters that were new to me opened up doors that allowed me to understand more about Scheuerer's world.  I consider characterization the strongest talent of this author.  She understands people and how to make characters come alive for readers.

In the acknowledgements Helen Scheuerer states that Reign of Mist focuses on the bond between sisters.  There are characters who are sisters that are prominent in this book.  I can see how the sister bond inspired Scheuerer to write Reign of Mist, but for me the central issue is the difficulty of weighing the consequences of actions.  Indeed this  novel shows that in some circumstances, the full ramifications  of a decision may not even be imaginable.

The ending of Reign of Mist seemed more resolved than the first novel in the trilogy.   It didn't feel like a cliffhanger.   I also thought that this is what was supposed to happen.  It makes for a satisfying reading experience.

                       
                         

Sunday, June 9, 2019

The Raven and the Reindeer: A Snow Queen Retelling For Pride Month

When The Raven and the Reindeer by T. Kingfisher was nominated as a June Book of the Month on a Goodreads group,  I was most interested in the Sami character that the nominator mentioned.  I have been interested in the Sami since childhood when my favorite book was Lapland Outlaw by Arthur Catherall.  The books that I've reviewed on this blog dealing with the Sami have been the thriller Forty Days Without Shadow by Olivier Truc  which I reviewed here and the mystery In The Month of the Midnight Sun by Cecilia Ekbäck which I reviewed here.  Although there is indeed a Sami character who plays an important role in The Raven and the Reindeer, she doesn't appear until late in the narrative.

Nevertheless, there were other very good reasons for me to read this T. Kingfisher book which I found delightful.  I'm glad that I purchased it on Amazon.

                             


The Raven and the Reindeer didn't become a book of the month, but there is currently an ongoing buddy read of the novel.  This is an adult retelling of The Snow Queen, a fairy tale by Hans Christian Anderson.   Participants, including me, have marveled about the elements from HCA's original tale that Kingfisher included which we hadn't remembered.  So it could be considered a fairly faithful retelling with several differences.

One difference is that the two crows in HCA's version are combined into one talking raven who is very snarky and entertaining.

Another more significant difference is that the protagonist needs to change shape in order to survive the cold of the journey to the Snow Queen's palace far in the north. Livli, the Sami character, has a very interesting idea about shapechanging.   She says that someone won't have barriers to such a transformation "when your own shape does not quite fit."  To me, this implies that non-cisgender individuals would be the humans who are most open to changing into another species.   Kingfisher doesn't actually explore this idea.  To my best knowledge, no one has written fiction about a pre-operative transsexual who also changes into an animal.   If someone has written fantasy or science fiction with that focus, I would love to read it.

The main reason why The Raven and the Reindeer was nominated for Pride Month is because it contains a lesbian relationship which definitely wasn't in HCA's original tale.  This relationship provided an ending to this retelling that made for a much better story for LGBT friendly readers.

                           





                         

Saturday, May 25, 2019

Heart of Mist: A YA Epic Fantasy With Believable Characters

I had no expectations when I received free copies of the entire Oremere trilogy from Helen Scheuerer via Book Funnel in order to participate in a Caffeine Book Tour for the final novel in the trilogy, War of the Mist, in July.  I only knew that the Oremere books are YA epic fantasy.

I am committed to write non-spoiler reviews for all three Oremere books.   This requirement always creates difficulties for me because the definition of spoilers varies so widely.  For these Oremere reviews I have decided to be guided by what Shealea, the Caffeine Book Tour Meister herself, has released in her post about this tour.  She tagged the Oremere series with several themes of interest.

                               

 
I'd like to discuss the use of alcoholism as a theme first because it was relatively prominent in Heart of Mist.  Readers who find this sort of content painful for personal reasons may want to avoid it, but I think it could be valuable to them. There was a scene in this book that raised an important point about alcoholism, and caused me to realize that I shouldn't give up on the character involved.

There was a sub-plot involving a blind character.  To my relief she wasn't some sort of improbable superhero.   I found her realistic.  Although it wasn't actually part of the plot, she also piqued my curiosity about writing by hand in braille.  I conducted a search on this subject and found instructions on WikiHow.

Finally, Shealea tagged the Oremere books for LGBT content.  In Heart of Mist, this was a minor theme that was dealt with briefly. That particular scene highlighted the issue of loyalty which is always of extreme significance in a military context.  There was no ongoing relationship in the LGBT category.

Plot-wise, I experienced Heart of Mist as the sort of book that builds slowly in intensity. There was a cliffhanger ending, so I was glad to have Reign of Mist waiting for me on my Kindle.

                         







                          

Saturday, May 11, 2019

Like Mayflies in a Stream-- A Fresh Approach to the Epic of Gilgamesh

When I came across Like Mayflies in a Stream by Shauna Roberts in an Amazon historical fiction search, I knew that it was a novel dealing with ancient Sumer.  I'm interested in reading books taking place in ancient times. So I purchased it and it languished on a shelf for years.  This year I added it to a Goodreads group TBR challenge and I'm glad I finally got to it.  You see, I hadn't known it was a  retelling of the Epic of Gilgamesh  with an unusual approach.

                              

I've read a number of Gilgamesh retellings dealing with the perspective of Gilgamesh, his companion Enkidu or the Goddess Inanna.  None dealt with the perspective of the people of Uruk under the rule of Gilgamesh.  This definitely wasn't a democratic society, but there were limits to what people were willing to endure.   There was such a thing as tyranny in ancient Sumer.  

Sumer was portrayed as a patriarchal society, but Gilgamesh's greatest atrocity in this novel was mistreatment of women.  Modern female victimization is often shown as an isolating event that separates the individual from her context.  Roberts shows the impact of  abuse of women on the men in their lives.  These women have fathers, brothers and husbands.  Family life was destroyed.

People in ancient times expected their gods to help them--particularly when there was a great injustice that was disrupting the social fabric.   They couldn't take their King to court or organize mass protests against his behavior.    Modern readers who live in constitutional democracies might think these Sumerians were pretty passive to have allowed these abuses to go on for so long.

Modern readers might also draw parallels between Gilgamesh and authoritarian figures in our era who believe that they can commit any wrong without penalty.  I felt that Like Mayflies in a Stream does speak to our time.   I could relate to the feelings of the people of Uruk that society was broken, and could never be restored to what it was before Gilgamesh uprooted all their norms.

This version of  the Epic of Gilgamesh is tragic, but it certainly has power.  I have placed this novel on my keeper shelf.  I will remember it for some time.

                       
                               

Sunday, April 21, 2019

Song For A Lost Kingdom-- A Novel of Music,Time Travel and Jacobites

I received Song For A Lost Kingdom from the Canadian author , Steve Moretti, via the promotional freebie website Prolific Works, and fell in love with the premise.  So I immediately volunteered to provide Moretti with feedback without having read a single word that he'd written.   I'm glad to say that I haven't regretted that impulsive decision since then.

                               


A facile description of Song For A Lost Kingdom would be that it's Outlander with music. This is true, but in a limited way.    If you love Outlander because it's about time travel to 18th century Scotland, then Song For A Lost Kingdom may be the sort of book that you'll enjoy.  Yet if you're an Outlander fan because of  the romance between Jamie and Claire, then you may be disappointed by Moretti's novel.  There is romance in the novel, but it isn't the central focus. The time traveling 21st century protagonist, Adeena Stewart, is a musician.  Music is Adeena's primary commitment in both time periods.   That's what I loved most about this book.  It shows that music can transcend time and place.

Another significant difference between Outlander and Song For A Lost Kingdom  is that the time travel method isn't what you would normally expect.  I read another novel that utilizes the same concept, but approaches it superficially.  Moretti gets extra points for making the fantastical seem so real.

Unfortunately, this time travel technique makes it easy for 21st century characters to believe  that Adeena is hallucinating rather than time traveling.  Even Adeena isn't sure about what's happening to her for almost the entire novel. She has serious medical problems.  Couldn't she also be mentally ill? Some readers might assume that the time travel is  an elaborate fantasy that's all in Adeena's mind.

It did seem to me that Adeena was irresponsible in some of her decisions.  This is partly the result of immaturity.  She is accustomed to being rescued which means that she never needs to grow up and face the consequences of her actions.    So she  is an ambivalent character.  Her dedication to the music she loves is admirable, but the wreckage of her personal life  could make readers want to slap some sense into her.  Some of us may find her similar to people in our own lives which makes her recognizable if not always likeable.

 Song For A Lost Kingdom is composed of  comfortable elements of the familiar and intriguing elements of the mysterious.   Yet it's the music that continued to haunt me.

                               


Sunday, April 14, 2019

The Scalpel and the Silver Bear--The Memoir of a Navajo Surgeon

When I first encountered The Scalpel and the Silver Bear by Navajo Dr. Lori Arviso Alvord, I wondered how she overcame the Navajo prohibition against contact with the spirits of the dead referred to as chindi in so many Tony Hillerman novels.  This barrier, and my curiosity about how traditional Navajo healing became part of her medical practice, were what drove my interest in reading this memoir.

                           

                               
 It did turn out that emotional discomfort over exposure to chindi was a hurdle for Alvord in medical school, but why didn't this issue arise when she first told her family that she planned to become a physician?  I discovered that Alvord came from a family who weren't traditionalists.  In fact, she was following her father's dream.

When Alvord graduated from medical school, she came back to Navajo country to serve her people at an Indian Health Service hospital.  Alvord initially thought that Navajo traditional healers could calm her patients before surgery, but she discovered that they could also use what sounded to me like a form of biofeedback to control bleeding.

Later Alvord went back to her alma mater, Dartmouth College in New Hampshire,  to teach medical students how to relate to Native patients.

I thought that Alvord's experiences were fascinating, and that she had a number of valuable insights to share with readers.  I also felt that The Scalpel and the Silver Bear was moving--particularly in the section that dealt with her difficult pregnancy.   I would recommend this memoir to anyone who is interested in Native Americans or in alternative approaches to medicine.