Search This Blog

Tuesday, January 27, 2026

She is Here: A Nicola Griffith Anthology

 I requested She is Here from Edelweiss in advance of publication because I have read this author, and thought I'd like an anthology of Nicola Griffith's work.   The books that I have read by this author are the novels Ammonite and Hild.  Unfortunately, I read them so long ago that I have no record of them, but I do have a good impression of these books which is why I decided to review She is Here.       

                                                  


                                                                                                

Griffith tells us that a writer is "a kind of  shaman"  which she defines as being able to "explore unknown territory and bring back maps".  Shamanic trance is an alternative state of consciousness.  Your mind is elsewhen.  There are no maps.

Griffith  continues from her author perspective to discuss immersion.  This means experiencing what a character experiences.  It's not only thoughts and feelings, but the sensory aspect--what the character sees, hears, smells and tastes.  In order to accomplish this, the writer must not only do research, she must be able to live within the book's context herself. 

In an article about branding for books and authors  that appears in She is Here,  branding is defined as "knowing who you are...and showing it".  I dispute this definition because it's author oriented and implies authenticity.  If you write a novel, self-publish it, and it has a few reviews on Amazon, you may be thrilled that anyone has read your book.  Yet such a book doesn't even require branding.

Branding is really  about selling a concept of a marketable product.  If you have a self-published book that only sold a few hundred copies, then it won't interest a major publisher.  They would say that there is no established market for this book. The marketing department at a major publisher develops the brand.  Branding is a commercial concept.  It involves what the marketing department can sell to the audience who is the market for the product. Major publishers want your book to sell hundreds of thousands of copies at the very least. They spend money on advertising their products, and they want to make a profit.  Authenticity doesn't even enter the equation.  In fact, commercial marketing inflates the value of a product through branding.  Authenticity goes out the window.  

I was reminded in this book that the Bechdel Test involves works that contain at least two female  characters who talk to each other about something other than a man. Griffith tells us that the disabled version of the Bechdel Test is The Fries Test  which was developed by Kenny Fries.  The disabled characters can't be cured or killed.  Fries is a memoirist, poet and librettist. Since I am interested in opera, I'd like to note in this review that he wrote the libretto for The Memory Stone for Houston Grand Opera which premiered in 2013.  For more about Kenny Fries see his Wikipedia article.

Griffith put out a call for book length manuscripts intended for adult readers that pass the Fries Test toward the end of 2017.   Eventually, she had a list of more than fifty submissions.  Of those fifty some were written some time ago, some were out of print and a few were in a foreign language.  Based on my own reading of fiction by disabled authors, I believe that most have dealt with the blind.  I don't know if a seeing individual in a wheelchair feels represented by fiction centering on blindness.  At that time, there were five million novels in English.  Griffith says that a census from a non-specified year recorded that one in five people were disabled.  So in order to represent the reality of English speaking people, the proportion of novels with disabled characters passing the Fries Test should be one in five. There would need to be one million novels that pass the Fries Test.  I don't think that will ever happen because the publishing industry is controlled by non-disabled people.

Griffith claims that a million novels centering on disability are needed  to "overwrite the corrosive influence of "ableism".  They wouldn't necessarily do that because the Fries Test  doesn't require that disabled characters be positively portrayed.  Some readers might say that positive portrayal is implied by the Fries Test, but I think it should be specified because non-disabled authors may be trying their hand at dealing with disability themes with no background in these topics.  They should immerse themselves in positive work by disabled authors before attempting their own works on this subject.

 I was glad to learn from this book that Griffith intended her novel Ammonite to challenge the science fiction writer Doc Smith's misogynist assumption that women aren't human without men. 

 Her novel Hild deals with the 7th century Abbess of Whitby Abbey which was founded as a double house that separately included both nuns and monks.  Griffith tells us that Hild means battle in Old Norse.  A search revealed that on Wisdom Library the name is associated with the Valkyries. This Abbess hosted the Synod of Whitby in 664 C.E. (Common Era) that dealt with trying to resolve the differences in the practices of the Celtic Church and the Roman Catholic Church. Hild was baptized in a mass conversion.  She probably wouldn't have known very much about Christianity then. The only biography of Hild is five pages long.   It emphasizes her visions and the miracles attributed to her. We also know that she advised royalty.  It isn't known where Hild was buried.

Griffith realized that she wanted to become a writer at Whitby Abbey.  She thinks of the Abbess Hild as having made both Whitby Abbey and her.  She was named  the 2025 Grand Master by the Science Fiction Writers Association.  

Despite this recognition, I have to say that  I liked this anthology, but didn't love it.  I'm giving it a B which will be three stars on Goodreads.

 

                                                    


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                   



 

                                                        

 

 


 




 


 

 



 


 

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

New York Times Book on Voter Suppression

I decided to read this library book because I'm interested in a book on voter suppression that was written by New York Times staff.   I subscribe to this newspaper and I respect it a great deal.  

I have a great deal of interest in voting and have always voted ever since I became eligible to vote.   I understand when people have challenging work schedules and can't manage to vote. Yet if they have relatively easy circumstances for voting in their precincts, I really don't understand why they absent themselves from the polls on Election Day.

                                                   


 I was amazed to learn that a national Election Day was established in 1845 in order to prevent fraud.  According to political science professor Michael McDonald, a single election day was considered to be needed so that people couldn't vote multiple times at more than one location. The U.S. has been obsessed with election fraud for almost two centuries. Consider how hard political organizations have to work to get people to vote at all, yet our leaders think that people would vote multiple times in the same election if they didn't actively prevent fraud.  Election fraud is actually so rare that it's nearly non-existent. Yet I predict that there will never be national elections held online because of the fear of fraud.

In 2002 the Help America Vote Act passed both houses of Congress. HAVA required all states to have electronic voting machines.  This doesn't mean that an individual precinct will have an electronic voting machine.  A precinct may be hand counting ballots.

I discovered that my impression that persons who had ever been convicted of a felony weren't allowed to vote in my state was completely wrong.  They are allowed to vote after serving their time.   I looked it up online.  This is the case in most U.S. states.  Though Republicans in Virginia and other states are trying to keep people with convictions from voting permanently.

The case of a woman who was released from prison in Florida was mentioned.  She was suing the state because she was charged $1000 in court fees that she considered a poll tax.  I imagine that she was considering it a poll tax because she needed to pay it in order to vote. That is a considerable barrier to voting for a newly released prisoner who will probably have difficulty finding employment.  

I learned about voter suppression of Native Americans in states where you must have a residential address.  Many Native Americans don't have residential addresses if they live on reservations.  Those Native Americans who are allowed to vote and register to vote, usually vote for Democrats. 

Then I read in this book about Maine Republicans ending voter registration on Election Day claiming it will stop voter fraud. Maine has had only two cases of voter fraud in 38 years.  The Republican governor of Wisconsin predicted that his state's voter ID law would cost Hillary Clinton votes.  In 2012 he claimed that the voter ID law would lower Obama's voter tally because Democrats cheat more often.  One of the few instances of voter fraud in Wisconsin was a vote for this same Republican governor.  Later in 2015 a staff aide to a Republican state legislator resigned because the Republican caucus was discussing voter ID bills as a means of suppressing the votes of college students and minorities.  

Photo ID laws mandating that voters must display their photo IDs when they vote tend to suppress the votes of the elderly and minority groups because an ID costs money.  The author of this article does consider requiring IDs to vote a kind of poll tax.  In Missouri, as of the publication of this book, the Missouri State Legislature had voted to approve a referendum in which Missouri voters will decide whether there should be a constitutional amendment requiring that voters show a photo ID when they vote. 

In an article on early voting, I discovered that a 1977 flood control proposition that was on the ballot in Monterey, California was the first modern American election decided by people who voted early.  The author of this article predicts that in the future campaigns may be starting up to six weeks before Election Day.  He must have meant local elections, not elections involving candidates for state or national office which start a great deal earlier.  

I was astonished to learn that in 1978 California was the first state to allow anyone to cast absentee ballots.  I would have thought that absentee ballots began earlier than that to allow soldiers who are serving outside their districts to vote. 

There is an article in this book with the title "The Student Vote is Surging, So Are Efforts to Suppress It" by Michael Wines.  In 2018 there was a poll taken at Harvard University.  45% of students aged 18-24 identified as Democrats, 24% considered themselves Republicans and 29% called themselves Independents.  Students became an important voting bloc in the 2020 election.  The Speaker of the Republican majority state legislature in New Hampshire promised to "clamp down" on students voting.  He said that students should be discouraged from voting because they have no life experience, but I encountered students who were working part time at a lower level in their professions while I was in graduate school.  They also did all the practical things that people who may have been high school dropouts have needed to master such as shopping for groceries, doing laundry and paying the rent.  

Disenfranchisement, as the New Hampshire Speaker of the State Legislature demonstrated, is an actual issue.  Voters recognize this. 3/4 of Americans say that the country is going in the wrong direction.  Gerrymandered districts cause certain voters to be favored over others.  So does the campaign finance system that gives corporations and the wealthy greater power. 

Another issue is that in most elections voters don't see any candidate that understands their problems.  So they end up voting against a candidate who they believe will make things worse rather than for one who will make their situations better. 

Almost every state allows ordinary citizens to challenge a voter's eligibility on or before Election Day.  I challenged a voter's eligibility once.  I was an election officer in several elections.  During one election, I did see someone enter the precinct a second time and stand in line to vote.  I informed the other election workers in case they hadn't noticed that this individual had already voted. The voter's signature on the rolls would have stopped this person, but I thought that the individual should have been escorted off the premises.

I spent some time poring over my notes on The New York Times articles in this volume because I care so much about this topic.  I want my readers to stay informed and please find the time to vote!

                                                     


 


 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

Friday, January 2, 2026

My 2025 Retrospective

                                               


                                                   

                                                                   Happy New Year  

                                                                                     2026    

            

 I hope you're having a happy 2026 so far.  Here are a few statistics for 2025.  

My most viewed post was as usual on Flying High Reviews which has a larger audience.  That post was the review of Laurie R. King's 2025 Mary Russell novel which can be found here.  The most viewed post on Shomeret: Masked Reviewer is the one reviewing  Renters Unite which is a book dealing with tenant organizing.  It can be found here. 

I read 30 books in 2025 which is three more than I read in 2024.  Well, it's not much of an increase, but reading more is an improvement over reading less.  Let's hope I can do better in 2026.  Since I'm starting off 2026 with a BFB (Big Fat Book), I might want to consider doing a page count at the end of next year in addition to the book count.  

I had eight five star reads in 2025.  I know that it's six more than in 2024. So I'm happy with that.  I'll be featuring brief comments about all of those eight reads in this post.

 1) Hidden Libraries by D. C. Helmuth

  With a degree in library science, no one will be astonished to learn that I love libraries. Through Hidden Libraries by D. C. Helmuth, I discovered libraries whose existence was totally unknown to me.

2)Hope Dies Last by Alan Weisman 

 This deals with environmentally destructive policies that have devastated what was once known as the Fertile Crescent, and an engineer's hope that the damage can be reversed.  I was so sorry about the conditions in the area of the Middle East that Weisman was discussing.

3)Red Flag Warning by Dani Burlison

Red Flag Warning deals with the ongoing tragedy of California wildfires. People losing their homes to the fires and having to evacuate is the most important news story for Californians.  I was particularly interested in reading about incarcerated firefighters who make up one third of California's firefighting force.  

4)Renters Unite by Jacob Stringer

This is a book dealing with tenant organizing.  There was a tenant demand that landlords charge the same for rent to poor families renting the landlords' properties as is charged for public housing. I considered this demand one that was unlikely to be met.

5)The Hidden History of American Oligarchy by Thom Hartmann 

This book deals with the various types of oligarchy in American history and the struggles we have had with oligarchy which includes the American Civil War with the Confederate oligarchy. 

6)Spell Freedom by Elaine Weiss

This volume focuses on voter participation in the Deep South, and the school founded by Myles Horton to educate Black voters on what they would need to know to participate in elections.

7)The Small and the Mighty by Sharon McMahon

There were well-known events from throughout American history, and information about racial and cultural minorities.

8)How To Be An Antiracist by Ibram X. Kendi

  Antiracism involves taking a stand to actively oppose racism. The goal of activists should be to bring racism to an end. Antiracism needs to be spread as widely as possible. 

I am delighted to be able to bring these worthy books to the attention of my audience once more.  I hope more people will read them as a result of this retrospective.

  


  

  

 

  

 

 

Wednesday, December 31, 2025

19th Century Women Struggle For Independence Through Music

The Choir by Carol M. Cram is a book that I obtained through Book Funnel.  I decided to read it because it deals with women who sing even though they aren't supposed to be able to do so.  I love to sing!  

 

                                               

 

 So this novel deals with British lower class women forming a choir in the 19th century.  They aren't expected to have the leisure to sing. The lower class are supposed to be continually struggling to survive.   The women in the choir must deal with marriage and family commitments plus long work hours that conflict with their performances.

This book also deals with a male character who is blackmailed for being gay.  Gay characters are an interest of mine, but the last time I reviewed a novel on this blog that deals with a gay character, it was Michelangelo in Michelangelo and the Stone Mistress back in 2022 here .  

I am sometimes sentimental. So I'll admit that when there was a positive resolution to a relationship in this novel that had turned romantic, there were tears is my eyes.  I hope that readers are also moved by the emotional intensity of  certain relationships within the pages of this novel.   

                                          

                                                  


 

Saturday, December 27, 2025

The Goal is to Eliminate Racism


I'm not aware of being racist, but that doesn't mean that I'm not.  Anti-racism is a step beyond thinking that I'm not a racist.  It's taking a stand that you will actively oppose racism. The book that I'm reviewing is How To Be An Anti-Racist .

                                                     

 

How To Be An Anti-Racist is the first book I've read by Ibram X. Kendi.  I think I may want to read The Black Camps Movement which is one of his previous works.  I definitely want to read his most recent book, Chain of Ideas, which I've placed on hold at the library. 

Some may think that racism causes no harm, but it definitely does.  It destroys the possibility of positive interaction with persons of other races.  Racism prejudices you against such a possibility.

 The book opens with Kendi as a teen.   He'd given an MLK Competition speech saying that Black youth believed that it was OK to be feared, not to think and not to value education.  He also said "They think it's OK to confine their dreams to sports and music."  He'd adopted a sports career as his aspiration himself.  He realized that he'd been reproducing racist ideas in his speech, but he ended that he still "had a dream" which is a reference to MLK's famous speech.  After that, he had nightmares about his racist speech.  

At that point I included this significant quote from How To Be An Anti-Racist:

" Internalized racism is the real Black on Black crime." 

One example of internalized racism was Kendi wearing hazel contact lenses.  He thought they made him look more White and that they looked better than his natural eye color which presumably looked more Black.  Why did he want to look more White? Why did he think it looked better? Kendi calls this Colorism which is a set of racist ideas about skin color.  So he was aware that this was racist, yet he continues to wear hazel contact lenses.  I consider this sad. 

Saying that you aren't racist means that you consider yourself neutral.  Kendi points out that  "there is no neutrality in the racism struggle".  You need to be fighting against the constructed hierarchy of the races in order to be anti-racist.  

It seems to me, that if racism is a fire that's burning down bridges between the races, you need to be anti-racist to fight the fire.

"Racist" isn't just an insult.  It describes the way someone categorizes other people.  You need to be able to identify racism in order to dismember the categorization process.

My father was part of the civil rights struggle as an active member of the American Civil Liberties Union.  I think he could be considered an anti-racist. 

"Our constitution is color blind," said U.S. Supreme Court Justice John Harlan is his dissent to Plessy v. Ferguson which legalized segregation in 1896.  Harlan also said that the White race would remain dominant "if it remains true to its great heritage."  This is a White supremacist statement, not a color blind one.  So Justice Harlan's statement should be considered unconstitutional.

"Racist" and "anti-racist" define thoughts and actions not "fixed identities", Kendi tells us.  Theoretically, we can be racist one minute and anti-racist the next.   Kendi no longer believes that a Black individual can't be racist.  He also no longer believes that the actions of a Black person reflect on him.  No one is a "race representative", but we need to focus on changing racist policies.  Unfortunately, I believe that so long as there are racist individuals, we can't prevent them from organizing to pass racist laws.  I don't consider that cynicism, I consider it realism.

Kendi says that the most threatening policy is race neutrality.  This is true for the same reason that a do nothing climate policy is the most threatening.  The non-white global south is the most victimized by climate change.  In the U.S.,  nearly 4000 areas that are mostly poor and non-white have higher rates of lead poisoning than Flint, Michigan.  Flint is pretty toxic, so that makes these 4000 areas ultra-toxic.  So if we had prioritized cleaning up poor non-white areas, the people who lived there wouldn't be dying of lead poisoning.

Kendi says that he is one generation removed from picking cotton.  I would like to point out that some Whites are also one generation removed from agricultural serfdom.  My grandmother was a serf which meant she worked in the fields involuntarily for no pay for a Polish count. I think that such exploitation was widely practiced in a number of parts of the world. 

One Black police officer was reported as saying that Negroes are "too stupid" to get a good education, so they could get a good job.  I guess when police are abusive and don't enforce the law properly, then being a cop is a terrible job. 

Kendi complains that 80% of teachers are White.  I recall reading that few Blacks can afford to train to be teachers in addition to taking the classes to get a B.A. as a prerequisite.

When I read about the hundreds of thousands of Black women having been involuntarily sterilized, I wrote in my notes that this was an attempt at medical race genocide. Another sign of medical race genocide was the statistic that Black women are three to four times more likely to die while pregnant than White women.  

Kendi points out the differences between protests and demonstrations.  I've always used these terms interchangably, but Kendi says they have specific definitions.  "A protest organizes people for a long lasting campaign that has the goal of bringing about change.  A demonstration is a short term mobilization to bring attention to a problem.  In that case, my most recent political actions have all been protests, not demonstrations.

I hadn't been aware that racist policies pre-exist racist ideas.  The ideas are elaborated in order to justify the policies.  This observation by Kendi made complete sense when I thought about it.  The reverse only makes sense in the context of someone studying racism.   Out in the real world, racist politicians want to start by implementing racism through policy.  

Of course the goal of rational people who want to live in a civilized society without racial conflict is to end racism.  That is what I hope for, and it's what Kendi hopes for too.  This attitude needs to spread as widely as possible.

                                                 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                  

 

 

                                                      

 

Saturday, December 13, 2025

Three or More is a Riot: An Essay Collection

 When I received a copy of Three or More is a Riot  by Jelani Cobb, it was an advance reader copy that was approved by Random House the publisher.  I needed to download it from NetGalley. This means it wasn't published yet.  I was reading a novel at the time. So I needed to finish that book.  Then it took me three weeks to read and mull over this essay anthology.  In that time period, a great deal has happened--including the publication of Three or More is a Riot.  So I'm late by the publisher's standards.  

                                                             


The title of this book is the definition of "riot" in the criminal code.  It's not a riot unless three or more people are involved in "concerted unlawful actions".  

Unlike many essay anthologies, this one is written by a single writer.  Jelani Cobb authored all 59 pieces included in the collection.  

Cobb discusses how mixed race Barack Obama was defined as black by both the black and white communities.  Yet he was brought up by his white mother to be culturally white.  I imagine that being culturally white allowed Obama to be elected President of the United States. 

Cobb cites a  2010 Pew poll whose results were that 55% of the total respondents viewed Obama as black while a third saw him as mixed race.  Cobb believes that the history of slavery, rape and random relationships means that there really aren't any genetically pure blacks.  I hadn't really thought of that. Cobb is right, of course.   

Cobb points out that the election of Obama couldn't change the "complex relations between African American men and law enforcement".  When I lived in a primarily African American neighborhood from the late 1980's to the early 21st century, what I saw wasn't "complex".  It was a poor relationship.  Police wanted to intervene during social events and celebrations.  

I am now doing research for this review on more recent black population shifts since The Great Migration in which many Southern blacks moved North.  Cobb mentioned that there is currently a high population of blacks in the South.  I learned online that there has been a Second Great Migration of young well educated Northern blacks to Atlanta.  I am very well aware of a black migration to California, but this new generation of blacks moving southward was unknown to me. 

My main source for this information is a website for The Brookings Institution.  The Brookings Institution is a think tank that does research on the social sciences.  It was formed in 1916 and is located in Washington D.C.  I had heard of The Brookings Institution, but had never previously used it as a source of research. 

 Cobb makes a reference to Lincoln having "preternatural political abilities".  I have never been a fan of Lincoln myself ever since I learned that he abolished slavery due to political pressure. You know, he had to deal with a civil war.  You'd think someone with "preternatural political abilities" could have ended it with a great deal less bloodshed.   Maybe he was more of a man of his time than a man for the ages.

 Author Cobb attended Howard University, one of the big four  HBCUs (Historically Black Colleges and Universities).  So he includes discussion of  HBCUs in this book.  Thurgood Marshall, Kamala Harris, Zora Neale Hurston and Toni Morrison are among those mentioned as graduates of HBCUs.  This implies that without HBCUs, it might have been a good deal more difficult for these important black figures to become prominent.  I had almost no awareness of HBCUs before reading this book.  So I was thoroughly educated in the significance of these institutions by reading Three or More is a Riot.

Cobb mentions that white run universities were segregated for decades. The university where I got my B.A. had few black students while I attended it.   I did notice that and imagined that the reason was financial, and that there was little availability of scholarships and financial aid for those students.  I knew that this was discriminatory, but didn't think I could do anything to remedy the situation.

I decided to take African American History.  The students in that class were almost entirely black.  It was assumed that whites like me wouldn't be interested in African American History.  Yet I was. I didn't know any African Americans, but I was a history major who was attracted to all types of history.   

So here's some black history.  In 1867 the main campus of Howard University was built.  Howard was intended to be a  university for blacks.  Its founder, Oliver Howard was a white man who thought very highly of African American soldiers that fought in the Civil War.  Howard was a general in the Union Army and had been appointed a Commissioner of the Freedman's Bureau.  Howard and the other trustees of the future Howard University purchased 150 acres of farmland on which the university would be built.  Charles Boynton, who had been the chaplain of the U.S. House of Representatives, was selected as Howard University's first president.  

The first black president of Howard wasn't appointed until 1926.  His name was Mordecai Wyatt Johnson.  He was so light skinned that he could be mistaken for white.  A photo of Johnson can be found in his Wikipedia article.

Charles Hamilton Houston, the first African American to make the Harvard Law Review, ran Howard University's law school.  Houston became future Supreme Court justice Thurgood Marshall's mentor.  The two of them were responsible for the lawsuits that integrated U.S. schools in the 1950's. 

In 1934 there was a protest in which a line of Howard students wore nooses around their necks.  The students were demanding that Attorney General Homer S. Cummings stop the dozens of lynchings that were occurring across the U.S.  I didn't know that there were lynchings outside the former Confederate South.  I found a very disquieting article about lynchings in other parts of the country here.

In 1963 Albert Manley, the president of HBCU Spelman College, fired Howard Zinn, the head of Spelman's history department, for encouraging future author Alice Walker to participate in the civil rights movement. Albert Manley  was worried that Zinn's advice would upset white donors.  Possibly, but I'm upset that Zinn was fired for that reason.

In 1968 the students at HBCU Tuskegee University shut down the school and made a demand for more focus on African American studies.  They posted a sign on the front of the administration building which said BLACK UNIVERSITY.

Plessy v. Ferguson is a famous case, but I've never read anything about the facts involved.  Now I know from this book that it dealt with segregation in Louisiana railroad cars.  Homer Adolph Plessy was hoping that the case would bring about a "crusade for civil rights", but it had the opposite effect, says Cobb.  I wondered how that happened.  I looked it up online and decided that 1896 was just too early for the argument of equality between the races to succeed at such a high political level.  

Cases related to Plessy v. Ferguson were Buchanan v. Warley (1917) which outlawed housing discrimination covenants and Corrigan v. Buckley (1926) which restored housing discrimation covenants, Smith v. Allright (1944) which prohibited the Texas laws that disallowed black and Mexican voters from participating in primary elections, Sweatt v. Pamter (1950) which prohibited the exclusion of blacks from the University of Texas law school, and Brown v. the Board of Education which ended school segregation in 1954.  Future U.S. Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall headed the legal team that won Brown v. the Board of Education.  He had more than thirty years of dealing with cases involving racial segregation.

Author Jelani Cobb is the dean of Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism.  He is also a staff writer at The New Yorker and the author of The Substance of Hope: Barack Obama and the Paradox of Progress.  He is also the producer of the documentary The Riot Report.  He won the Peabody Award and was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in Commentary and is on the board of trustees of the New York Public Library.

I gave this book an A- because although this book is excellent and very thorough, I didn't read anything in it that was unexpected. 

                                                 

 


 


 

 

  

 

 

 

 



 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                                 

                                  

Sunday, November 2, 2025

Eaarth: Dealing With Our Longterm Environmental Disaster

  I lost interest in two books that I intended to read.   I'm now reading a used copy of a book that I purchased from my favorite bookstore.  The book is called Eaarth by Bill McKibben.  McKibben has re-named our planet because it's changed so radically due to environmental damage.

                                                     


 I'm starting this post on the last day of October 2025.  I wanted to finish Eaarth today to include it in my October reads.  I met that goal. This will be a long complicated review involving research, so I am very likely to be working on it in November.  I am glad to have had Bill McKibben's insights on environmental change.

What if illegal immigration to the United States is driven by climate ? I've never seen media speculation on the root causes of all this migration.  It's something to ponder while I read the headlines scrolling across the bottom of my TV screen as I watch the news.  

When I read in this book that petroleum supplies are dwindling , I looked up the number of electric buses that my local bus company has, and was alarmed by how few they were.  They've got to get to the goal of total electric conversion of their bus fleet ASAP.   Then I looked up the train system I use to get to other cities.  I was relieved to learn that they are 100% electric. 

 Another issue brought up in Eaarth is corporate agriculture causing economic difficulties.  Since corporate agriculture employs few people, it can result in more unemployment and crime.  People have to feed themselves.  If there are no legitimate jobs available, they may resort to illegitimate means of obtaining income.

 In one agricultural area in Brazil, there were once eleven subsistence farms.  Now there is a single corporate soybean operation, and the peasants have relocated to the edge of cities living in cardboard boxes. That sounds like the tragic circumstances of homeless people in the United States. There are increasing similarities between the U.S. and the Third World.

McKibben points out that suburbans have enough land around their homes that they could grow their own food.  He thinks that even New York City residents could supply 10-20%  of the produce they need by growing it themselves.  But what about NYC's pollution?  If I knew that food had been grown in a polluted environment, I would avoid it.  The reason why I eat organic is to avoid toxic chemicals.

McKibben mentions lack of sufficient water as a limitation for suburbans growing their own food.  He gives Las Vegas as an example where suburban agriculture wouldn't work.  I stayed with someone who lived in the suburbs of Las Vegas, and everyone had a garden.  According to Southern Nevada Water Authority, 90% of Las Vegas' water comes from the Colorado River and 10% comes from local ground water. 

As for New York's power, McKibben believes that rooftop solar and wind turbines could meet 81% of New York's power needs, but it seems to me that in some neighborhoods the solar panels would be stolen.  These neighborhoods would probably be too accessible for their own good.

McKibben thinks that since North Dakota can provide 14,300% of its needs, almost entirely through windmills, they could theoretically provide energy to other regions, but it would cost $100 billion to build the transmission lines.  So it would be cheaper for every locality to produce energy locally, if possible.  An Ohio wind farm would employ local people and the profits from getting it financed would go to Ohio banks, McKibben points out. 

Some people think windmills are ugly.  I don't understand that perspective and neither does McKibben.  We both think that windmills are beautiful. I've always admired medeival windmills.  McKibben says windmills are "the breeze made visible".  That's very poetic.

McKibben thinks that every region of the U.S. could potentially produce clean energy.  Hydropower could be an industry in the Northwest,  offshore wind could be generated on the East Coast, solar energy in the Southwest and in the Southeast biomass from forests could be the main source of sustainable power. 

McKibben blames the big utilities, who want to keep their power monopolies, for preventing clean energy from being implemented.  No doubt that's true. Yet OTOH,  McKibben says there are small companies that are using micropower plants to power a single building or a campus.  That's been 1/3 of all new power businesses in the U.S.   It plays a bigger role in the U.S. economy than new nuclear or coal plants. 

An article I found dealing with mini hydropower plants states that they are a major factor in irrigation projects throughout the world.  Bali was particularly mentioned as an example. 

  I imagine that small scale ventures will be the most successful means of implementing clean energy for the foreseeable future.