Search This Blog

Monday, September 12, 2022

Navajo Photographer Protagonist in a Mystery

 In order to make sure I would get a mystery read in September, I got one picked out even before I'd arrived at the halfway point. It was Shutter by Ramona Emerson.  The copy I'm reviewing is a library book.  The protagonist is a photographer which isn't all that unusual.  I've reviewed several books with photographer protagonists on this blog-- most recently Michael Angelo & the Stone Mistress by Steve Moretti.  Yet this is my first Navajo photographer protagonist. 

                             
                                 



As the book opens, Navajo Rita Todacheene is a forensic photographer.  This means that she photographs crime scenes. Yet she also sees spirits which isn't a trait that would be considered compatible with professionalism in most work environments.  Needless to say, Rita must be careful not to reveal her paranormal gift  to officers in the Albuquerque PD. 

Being paranormally gifted, isn't the only way that Rita's job is problematic. I also knew that the Navajo avoid mentioning the dead or even the names of dead relatives.  So it seemed to me that Rita's job was extremely incompatible with her culture.  

The issue of the Navajo belief that the spirits of the dead (called "chindi" in mysteries by Tony Hillerman) could contaminate them, arose when Grandma took Rita to a church where ghosts were lingering.  I wondered why Navajo spirits of the dead would linger if they believed they were contaminating people that they loved.  Her grandfather's spirit worried that inimical spirits could make Rita crazy.

I was interested in the fact that Rita's neighbor was evidently a curandera.  Curandismo is a a Mexican healing tradition. She rubbed Rita with an egg, then she cracked the egg into a glass of water and told Rita to put the egg in the glass of water under her bed.  "Whoever has their eye on you will let you go," said the curandera.  There were also jars to put in each corner of the room.  Rita thought it was superstition.  I think that Rita's lack of belief in the measures that Rita's neighbor was taking to protect Rita would undermine their efficacy.

<Spoilers--

Rita learned Police Lieutenant Garcia was behind most of the local distribution of meth. This was a major revelation.  I wondered if Garcia did that because Latinos were being discriminated against when it came to advancement in the police department.  

End spoilers.>

It was mentioned in this book that Saint Veronica is the patron saint of photography.  Since I had never heard this before, I looked for a confirming link.  I found it at St. Veronica which links to a page about this saint's connection to photography.  Since Rita doesn't seem to be a devout Catholic, I didn't think that St. Veronica would have been significant for Rita.

There is a positive resolution to the book from a law enforcement perspective.  I decided to give the book a B+


                             



Sunday, August 28, 2022

The Ambiguous Impact of Simone Weil

 I decided to read On The Abolition of All Political Parties by Simone Weil translated from French by Simon Leys because the title attracted my attention.  I also wanted to read a translated book by a woman during August which is Women in Translation month.

 

                                                                 


Simon Leys says in his translator's forward that "taking a conscience vote" in Parliament should be considered a pleonasm.  Pleonasm was an unfamiliar word to me.  I looked it up and discovers that it means redundancy.   

I wondered about Leys' perception.   Aren't members of Parliament supposed to be representing their districts, not themselves as individuals?  So therefore it's not true that they should always be voting according to their own beliefs.  They should be doing what their constituents want and need.  Representing their constituents is what's expected of members of Congress in the United States.  If  members of Congress don't do that, then the United States fails as a democracy. 

Leys, writing in 2012, says that although Weil wrote On The Abolition of All Political Parties 70 years ago, it's particularly relevant now.  Looking at politics in the United States in 2022, I think it's not just relevant but urgent.  I am an Independent who doesn't subscribe to political parties.   I realize that I am in the minority in my extremely partisan country.  

Weil writes that people join political parties in order to be politically effective even if the party doesn't represent their own beliefs and principles.  I don't understand why voters don't consider it counter-productive to achieve political success at the price of sacrificing their principles.  That isn't a victory for the voters.   It's a victory for the politicians who want to have power. 

Poet Czeslaw Milosz's essay "The Importance of Simone Weil" was included in this volume.  Milosz tells us that Simone Weil's support for labor unions caused her to go to work in factories for a year to experience what labor was like.  She contributed her pay to the labor unions.  Milosz says that Weil felt like a slave after having worked in the factories.  She died of malnutrition in a sanitorium.   I have questions.  Was her commitment to that institution voluntary or involuntary?  Did she die of malnutrition because she refused to eat or because the institution was starving her?   The answers to these questions would determine how I see Simone Weil.  

Weil apparently considered the Roman Empire a totalitarian society.  Totalitarianism was impossible until the existence of surveillance technology.  The Romans weren't capable of being totalitarians in our modern sense.  

Milosz said that both he and Albert Camus were drawn to Weil because of her certainty.  Camus was an atheist who doubted atheism and Milosz was a Christian who doubted Christianity.   Simone Weil had said that there were Pagans who were "naturally Christian" and Christians who were "naturally Pagan".  It seems to me that religious beliefs aren't innate.  There is no such thing as a natural adherent to a religion.   You are persuaded to become a religious adherent by your exposure to the religion and its beliefs.  

If I had to try to sum up the influence of Simone Weil on our present times, I don't think that I could do it.  There are unanswered questions that make her life and legacy unclear to me.  So I am inconclusive about Simone Weil at this point.

 

                                           




   

                              


                             





Friday, August 26, 2022

The Clerk's Tale: A Medieval Mystery With Too Many Characters

 I purchased a used copy of The Clerk's Tale by Margaret Frazer from a library sale cart.  It's the 11th book in a mystery series.  There have been 17 books in this series.  I've read a number of them long ago before I was online which was late in the 20th century.  I don't recall having read this particular book.  I'm sure it didn't exist when I was reading earlier books in this series.

I've seen reviewers complain about an excessive number of characters making a novel too complex to follow.  This is the first time that I thought so.  Maybe I'm losing the ability to track all these characters that I once had.  All I know is that I had to page back more than once to where characters were introduced in order to identify them. I also wished that I had been reading this book on Kindle so that I could find past references to characters more easily.  It occurs to me that Kindle features have made me a lazy reader.  I don't have to remember a long list of characters and who they are, if I can find that information using Kindle searches.  It's a possibility.   

Now I need to get into other aspects of The Clerk's Tale, so I can consider this a proper blog review. 

 

                                 cover image THE CLERK'S TALE: A Dame Frevisse Medieval Mystery  

 

While I was reading this book, it seemed odd to me that characters mentioned that Nichola was rather young to be a wife at sixteen.  I've read that it was common during the medieval period to marry girls in their teens to men in their thirties or forties.  I've seen many references in  books to fourteen year old medieval wives. Yet in a search I did for this review, I found an essay here called "This Is What It Was Like To Be A Teenager in the Middle Ages" by Oxford history professor Rachel Moss that indicated that marrying adult men to teen girls wasn't a common practice during that period, and states that medieval people were aware that teenagers weren't fully mature.  So it seems that  The Clerk's Tale is more accurate than other medieval novels that I've read containing teen brides.

Lady Agnes asks protagonist Sister Frevisse to read aloud a Chaucer tale that I've never heard of called "The Tale of Sir Topas".  Apparently, Chaucer intended it to be humorous.  The characters who listened to Frevisse read it laughed.  So apparently Chaucer succeeded in conveying humor to them.  I'm not sure if I would have reacted similarly.  Chaucer might have been disappointed with my reaction. When I read the summary which said that it involved a search for the Elf Queen, I thought that I would have been more intrigued than amused.  But then, I'm a fantasy fan. 

Getting into the mystery aspect, which didn't interest me as much as the historical context, I wondered why the jury for one of the murders was formed from people who experienced an event associated with the murder.  Perhaps during the medieval period objectivity wasn't considered as important in the jury selection process as it is now. It seemed like trials were ad hoc affairs, and that having the trial take place ASAP was a much greater priority than it is now.  The trial took place before an investigation was called for which seems backwards to me. 

 I've read many medieval mysteries that didn't seem so alien as this one did.  I think that the mystery aspect wasn't as strong as the history content.  Yet there was also some good character development which increased my estimation of the book.

                           


         

       


 

Sunday, July 31, 2022

We Organize to Change Everything: An Abortion Essay Anthology

 I received a copy of this anthology of abortion essays for review from the publisher.

Below are the significant comments about this book from my journal that I'm willing to put on the internet.  

                                  


                                

In the first essay by Jenny Brown, she refers to Neoliberalism.  She means the British version of liberalism.  People who aren't aware that "liberal" once had another meaning might be confused. It's based on an older definition of liberalism that goes back to the 18th century, a philosophy that supports freedom, equality, human rights and democracy, as opposed to monarchy or other types of authoritarianism.  See the Wikipedia article on the subject here.  In the 19th century liberalism evolved into a political philosophy of free enterprise.  It still retains that meaning in the modern UK.  In the U.S., it essentially means the opposite.  It's a preference for government intervention in order to assist minorities and the impoverished.  This is another example of "two great nations separated by a single language".  Oscar Wilde originally said something similar in The Canterville Ghost.  

It entertains me to think that the Hyde Amendment is related to Robert Louis Stevenson's character Mr. Hyde who turned into a monster. This is a law that doesn't allow the U.S. federal government to fund anything involving abortion unless the abortion saves the life of the mother, or is the result of rape or incest.  I do find the practical results of the Hyde Amendment rather monstrous.  Non-consensual pregnancies aren't in the interest of mothers, children or families in general.

In the essay "Labor Crisis in the Clinics" two Planned Parenthood workers have a discussion with journalist Amy Littlefield.  I mention it in this review because I learned from this essay that some Planned Parenthood workers are unionized, and that the relationship of the union with those who run Planned Parenthood is very adversarial.  I will never think about Planned Parenthood the same way again.

One of the essayists in this anthology says she had been a supporter of abortion rights since she was ten years old. I hadn't even heard the word "abortion" at that age. I feel that there is a vast chasm that has opened up between the world of my childhood and the world that I live in now.  

I learned some things that I hadn't known, but more importantly this book caused me to think more about the topic of abortion than I had previously.  I'm glad I read this book.


                        



Tuesday, July 5, 2022

Phasers on Stun

I purchased Phasers on Stun  from an independent bookstore after having seen it in the bookstore's window.  I am a Star Trek fan, and I thought this book might contribute to my knowledge of recent Star Trek  developments.  This is my first July read.

Readers may wish to know that I reviewed  Beaming Up and Getting Off , the most recent version of Walter Koenig's memoir , here. Walter Koenig played Ensign Chekov on ST: TOS (The Original Series)

                                     


Author Ryan Britt is a journalist.  In this book, he deals with all the extant versions of Star Trek in depth.  If any version of Star Trek changed your world, you might find what Britt has to say about it significant. 

I was delighted to see Britt's comments about spoilers.  He says that there have been studies which prove that spoilers don't ruin anything.  He points out that spoilers are taken out of context.  So the experience of learning about a spoiler is very different from viewing it in the context of the entire work.  I have often experienced this.  I like spoilers.  They help me to decide whether I'd like a book, a TV show or a movie.  I never feel that the experience of reading or viewing the material in its entirety has been ruined by the spoiler.  In fact, if I thought the spoiler was rather wonderful, I anticipate it and it increases my enjoyment of  the complete work.

 At times, I found Britt very patronizing .  He calls Star Trek "kitsch" and "goofy".  I resented his attitude.  He seemed to be completely unaware that he was offending fans.  Fans aren't just people who watch a series.  They love it, they identify with it and it becomes a significant part of their lives.  I imagine that Britt immersed himself in Star Trek for the purpose of writing the book, but he probably couldn't imagine the mindset of a Star Trek fan.  So it doesn't occur to him that he's alienating a good proportion of his readers with his patronizing comments.  He probably thinks that people who read his book secretly share his opinion of Star Trek.  I hate to break it to him, but no they don't if they are genuinely fans of the Star Trek universe.  There was a time in my life when Star Trek: TOS felt extremely meaningful to me.  It doesn't feel the same way to me now, but I don't disown those feelings.  TOS is a part of me.

 I was shocked to learn from Britt that TPTB (The Powers That Be-- in this case it means the show runners) consulted with a man who fraudulently claimed to be an American Indian to determine if Chakotay on Voyager was authentic.   The man who called himself  Jamake Highwater was actually Jack Marks, and he had no Native American ancestry.   If I were going to use someone as an expert in a certain area, I would vet them first. 

Britt thinks that the ratio of those who have seen the Star Trek movie, First Contact, compared to those who have seen the ST:TOS episode Metamorphosis must be a thousand to one.  Well,  I'm one in a thousand then.  I thought "Metamorphosis" was a beautiful and moving episode, and I absolutely despised  the portrayal of Zephrem Cochrane in First Contact.  Ugh!  It would be hard for me to find a worse translation of a character, who had been portrayed earlier, into film.

Toward the end of this book, there is a reference to fans wearing buttons saying "I like REAL Star Trek, forget that bald guy."  My equivalent button would be "I like REAL Star Trek, forget the White guys."  You see, in my favorite Star Trek a Black man is in command, Avery Brooks. 

I loved Deep Space Nine from the very first episode.  I thought the characters were awesome particularly Dax who is a Trill.  Trills are ancient beings whose personalities are inserted into different individuals over time. Jadzia Dax is a young woman and was the most recent Dax.  We see earlier hosts for the Dax symbiont in flashbacks.  I find this very fascinating.

It was enjoyable to re-live the earlier Star Treks that I've seen through Phasers on Stun and to learn about the newer series that I haven't seen. I'm considering viewing Discovery and Strange New Worlds.  There's just so much for me to catch up on in digital format.  


                                      



 

 


 

                                    



 

Monday, June 20, 2022

Disability Pride

Disability Pride by Ben Mattlin was a book that I downloaded from Edelweiss, which provides digital copies of books in advance of publication.  Mattlin's book is scheduled to be published in November 2022.  I feel privileged to have read it early.

 

  My review of Disability Pride appears below.

                                      


 

 I have written on disability topics previously on this blog.  Most of my focus in this area has been given to books dealing with deafness or deaf issues.  This was due to my co-blogger relationship with deaf author and fashionista, Tara Chevrestt. 

(Update on Tara: Tara is now primarily blogging about fashion at  Pin Up Gals , and I have re-shaped what was originally her blog called Book Babe as a blog dealing with books centering on strong female protagonists called Flying High Reviews.) 

 If you would like to see my posts about books dealing with disability see my review of Disabled People Destroy Science Fiction (which is a sarcastic title) here, my review of a novel about a mute woman protagonist here, my review of a novel taking place at a deaf boys' school in the UK here, my review of a novel about a 15th century non-disabled Jewish woman with a deaf father here, and my review of Inside Deaf Culture here.

The author of Disability Pride, Ben Mattlin, was born with spinal muscular atrophy.  He couldn't sit himself up as a baby, and he has never stood or walked.  It's a progressive disease which means his condition is worsening. Yet he is married, and they have two daughters in their twenties.

As a former New York resident I was interested to learn that there are only 124 subway stations that are accessible for disabled passengers.  There are a total of 472 subway stations.  In 2020 a federal judge ruled that the New York MTA must add elevators to every station that is renovated.   The MTA  hopes to make 70 more stations ADA accessible by 2024.

 The next issue that I need to discuss in the context of this review is support animals that are not allowed in the cabin during a plane trip.  This is supposed to be considered discrimination.   Airlines do allow animals that are small enough to sit on a passenger's lap or under the seat.  If they are too large to do either of those, I suspect it's probably a safety issue rather than discrimination. When food and drinks aren't being served, aisles must be kept clear in case of an emergency. I think that's common sense. 

This book mentions a 19th century individual with a disability who I think should be celebrated.  He is Thomas Wiggins, a blind man who toured performing music he himself had composed. Wiggins was invited to the White House to perform for President James Buchanan. I found a page on the Black Past website devoted to Thomas Wiggins here.

I also recently saw opera singer Andrea Bocelli perform on television and didn't realize that he was blind.  If I were a fan of Bocelli who followed his career, I probably would have. Although I enjoy opera, I admit that the performers whose careers I do follow are singers of either folk songs or popular music. 

I was shocked to learn from Disability Pride that in the 19th century it was illegal for disabled people to appear in public in San Francisco.  There were other cities where this was also a crime.  Chicago kept the law against disabled people on the streets longest.  It was enacted in 1881 and repealed in 1974.  Most disabled people were beggars which was considered a disturbance of the peace. People were actually arrested for the crime of being disabled and appearing in public!

Neurodiversity was coined in 1988 by an autistic Australian graduate student named Judy Singer.  It was derived from the term "biodiversity" .

According to the CDC, one in 59 Americans is autistic.  By the way, I had to figure out that Mattlin meant the CDC.  Sometimes this author's meaning needs to be deciphered.  He has a highly individual way of expressing himself.

I learned from this book that Greta Thunberg is autistic.  The author comments that idolizing famous autists like Thunberg is a distraction from normalizing neurodiversity.  Excuse me, I admire Thunberg for what she has done as a climate activist.  I imagine there are a great many people who don't know that she's an autist.  It seems to me that focus on Thunberg  probably doesn't impact the cause of normalizing neurodiversity one way or another.  But that's just me.

I would like to bring up a piece of litigation that was discussed in Disability Pride.  In 1995 two institutionalized women with disabilities sued the state of Georgia to receive treatment at home.  The primary plaintiff was Lois Curtis, an autistic Black woman.  Their doctors agreed that they would be able to live at home if they had the support to do so.  The state denied them, but it was appealed to the Supreme Court by Georgia's Commissioner of Human Resources, Thomas Olmstead.   The case was decided in favor of the plaintiffs.  Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote the majority opinion which stated that people who needed treatment for mental illness that could be treated in a community setting, should be allowed to live in the community if that is their preference. Such individuals could not be institutionalized against their will.  I found a page from The Arc, an advocacy and education organization for disabled individuals, that honored Lois Curtis this past February in the context of Black History Month here .  I hope that Lois Curtis continues to be remembered as a pivotal figure in the struggle for the rights of disabled people.  

Although my notes on this book took up half a book journal volume, I've already included all the comments that were substantive.  I thought this was an interesting and insightful book, though as I've mentioned I sometimes had a hard time figuring out what Mattlin intended to say.

             

                                  





Wednesday, June 15, 2022

Forever Past: Volume 3 in a Claire Clairmont Mystery Trilogy

Like the first two volumes in this trilogy dealing with the life of Claire Clairmont, I was requested to review this one by the publicist who is now MaryGlenn M. Warnock. Warnock mailed me a hardcover copy which I began reading on June 10, setting aside the book I was reading at the time.                                         

 For background on Claire Clairmont see my reviews of the previous two books in the trilogy.  My review of Claire's Last Secret can be found here , and my review of A Shadowed Fate is here.  

When I wrote the original version of this review, there was no cover for  Forever Past and the page for the novel on Goodreads was incomplete.  There is now a cover for this book which I am adding below.  

                                    60912643. sy475

                                

Claire in continuing to try to discover what happened to her daughter, Allegra, whose father was the poet Lord Byron.  Byron was his title.  His actual name was George Gordon.  (See the Wikipedia article on Lord Byron here.) He recognized Allegra as his daughter.  So it seems to me that her name would have been Allegra Gordon.

Setting the issue of what her name should be aside, Byron was trying to protect Allegra from assassination due to her being his daughter.  He himself was continually dealing with such threats.  Her life would be safe if no one knew where she was.    

Byron's involvement in a radical secret society would seem likely to have been the reason behind the assassination threats.  Certainly, keeping Allegra far from his political activities would have had a protective effect. 

The thriller aspect of this book eventually comes to a climax.  Some readers would have found those developments surprising.  I was briefly surprised, but current politics caused me to realize that I shouldn't have been astonished at all. 

There was a happy ending for Claire in this novel. There had not been a happy ending for her in real life.  I did think that the alternate events described in this book were possible. I like happy endings when they aren't completely beyond the realm of possibility.   So I thought Forever Past  was credible.  I gave it a B.